Maynard earned much acclaim and Drama Desk and Lortel Award nominations for his performance in Altar Boyz. He left the show in July to prepare for a role in another off-Broadway musical, Miracle Brothers, which ended its limited run on October 16. His other theatrical credits include Mamma Mia! on Broadway, the Encores! mounting of Bye Bye Birdie, the tour of On the Record and the pre-Broadway mounting of Good Vibrations at Vassar College's Powerhouse Theater. Maynard can also be seen in the Todd Solondz film Palindromes.